Utah Supreme Court Dismisses Navajo Nation Appeal


The Utah Supreme Court has dismissed an appeal by the Navajo Nation to undo the adoption of two Navajo siblings by a non-Native American couple due to the tribe’s failure to file the appeal with the tribe’s signature on time, according to a piece published by the Salt Lake Tribune on Sept. 28.

The ruling, issued this week, marks the first time that the justices have held that neither the Indian Child Welfare Act nor the quasi-sovereign status of tribes trump state filing requirements, the article said.

Attorneys for the adoptive parents, Ricardo and Suzi Ramos, first argued the case on May 1, 2009.

“We think this is a very fair and just result, especially when taking into consideration the best interests of these two children,” Wes Hutchins, a Ramos’ attorney, told the Tribune.

The children, Ella and Anthony, both enrolled members of the Navajo Nation, were adopted by the couple in 2008, two years after they were brought into the family as foster children. The couple has said that they have kept the kids connected to their heritage.


  1. Anonymous says:

    Our future and valuable resource of Indian children belong with their respective tribes to learn their tribal customs and traditions. These children learn them and practice them to become a part of their tribe, the future leaders of tomorrow, parents, grandparent, elders, family and the communicty all have a part in teaching these children to belong to their tribe. Non-Indians don't know our traditional ways and view them as being foreign, how can they teach these children their tribal customs and traditions when they don't belong to the tribe.

    As a tribal member am very protective of our children and their place with the tribe, our beliefs are strong in the customs and tradtionals; it is our duty to pass these teachings to them and so on and so forth.

  2. Anonymous says:

    Yes, what he/she said! I couldn't have said it better! I was adopted out to whites in 1948 and not only lost what was to be so cherished, a natural mother and father, but my heritage. All I know is my Tribe is Lakota Sioux.
    Fight for your children! I missed it all!

  3. This post offers clear idea for the new people of blogging, that actually how
    to do blogging and site-building.

  4. Macedon says:

    I was recommended this website via my cousin. I am no longer certain whether or
    not this submit is written by him as no one else understand
    such unique approximately my trouble. You’re incredible!
    Thank you!

  5. Have all of the guests stand in a-line with their hands folded behind their backs.

    Each hand must certanly be holding another youngster’s hand.
    More Than 16 countless users perform Cafe area per month.

  6. You’ll discover coloring pages to start with on these pages.

    Warner Brothers’ Harry Potter site has four
    full-page Harry Potter coloring for kids. These simple points stimulate their
    imaginations and thrill kids.

  7. Then you will get a dollar each and every time you
    level-up. Some could be granted as presents from your own large neighbors.
    New objects indicates more people (and time playing) which increases the sport’s popularity.

  8. They showed the rabbits again in 1970, 1971, and 1972 where time
    they became an accepted type.
    Here are a few of my finds for free realistic animal websites to print out and color.

  9. Oliver says:

    Memberships can be found in several conditions. Rosemary’s world
    becomes more sinister and she starts to think in a conspiracy regarding her unborn child.
    They’re also utilizing the phone to track his place.

  10. Lee says:

    You may rarely find any anti- measures for these units.
    Search for discolouration or locations thinning, in addition to examining the fit.
    You should use the TinyUmbrella software to save lots
    of the SHSH of one’s iPhone.

  11. Quinton says:

    For any item, warranty is vital, so that it
    gets restored in the event of any injuries or malfunction. Believe me,
    be extremely happy with it, and you may prefer buying a 32
    GB iPad for the present time.

  12. Web sites preserve you not only in a few momemts but maybe hours and all day.
    Rushkoff feels that individuals can forsake Facebook and only genuine
    property websites, but I disagree.

  13. Party online because they were at the center of a vital struggle from not taking
    care of their kids. Even so, the second video-game
    system of Microsoft has a lot of technique-selling software.

  14. Kenton says:

    Consumers must observe that this is obviously a copycat move of what Apple has
    already accomplished.
    Additionally, it has a tendency to avoid spotting one-of my television receiver cards in the pc.

  15. To losing everything – all to get a videogame.
    The best selling game on the Xbox was Halo. That is an exceptionally
    dangerous shift. Fighting a policeman puts you in a
    3 star pursuit.

  16. Chas says:

    Hello! Do you know if they make any plugins to help with
    SEO? I’m trying to get my blog to rank for some targeted keywords but I’m not seeing very good results.
    If you know of any please share. Thank you!

    Feel free to surf to my page: google.ca; Chas,

  17. Why users still use to read news papers when in this technological globe everything is presented on web?

  18. blogspot.com says:

    Wish to crop your picture, adjust the brightness and distinction, or
    include some inventive touch to the pictures?
    It’s personal and immediate, whether or not through SMS or utilizing much more current messaging services like Whatsapp.

  19. This system removes purposes and packages from your own Windows PC.
    When the BIOS and CMOS settings of one’s pc have already been interfered with, a shutdown issue may result.

  20. King says:

    Amintiți-vă acele zile de pe bancheta din spate rendez – vous sau de luare în cinema ?
    Urmatorul cel mai comun este “Eu sunt într-o grabă ” câștigător “, litrotica ” , la 605 de ortografie eronate pe
    zi . Nu am avut nici un interes și actualizate aceasta ca întreg Malarkey .

  21. Firstly, an Ipod Itouch jailbreak is risk-free. This is also a give you that has been extended.
    If you’re fanatic to retro atmosphere then you may go along
    with Etch a Sketch event.

  22. Additional, the warranty of the iPhone will stand null and void.
    They improve the firmware and also prevent the blocks that are offered by SONY.
    Cydia enables you to include thousands of applications
    in your iphone.

  23. You can also use it to take photos or established voice reminders for yourself.
    Let us find out all about Fb Home when you decide to use it on your Samsung Galaxy S III.
    So you can download as many songs as you like.

  24. Grant says:

    Another of the most well-liked is a two megapixel digital camera.
    Add the Source for the Frash app by tapping Sources, Edit,
    and Include. By the time the installation total, obtain Frash.deb and maintain it nearby.

  25. There will be a couple of button presses
    at certain occasions. Sharepod is absolutely nothing more
    than a software program for you to sync your iPod and iphone.
    Now the query come up whether it will damage your iPad?

  26. Get an app called Pwnage Device 2.0.1, as well as firmware
    3G iPhone 2.0 0A347.

  27. De fapt , World Wide Web poseda ne afectează un număr
    semnificativ . Trebuie să fii sigur că site-ul dvs. este
    vizitat de oameni . În plus, ele depind de motoarele de căutare pentru a ajuta .

  28. Having read this I thought it was really informative.

    I appreciate you finding the time and energy to put this information together.
    I once again find myself spending way too much time both reading and posting
    comments. But so what, it was still worth

    Have a look at my blog: how to install a skylight on a tile roof

  29. În prezent, indiferent mea extinsă de restaurante continuă
    să fie ” cernut ” în categorii sub .

  30. Boyd says:

    And there’s nothing illegitimate about this. This naturally establishes that PS
    Jailbreak works for real! Disclaimer: We do not propose Jailbreaking your iPad.

  31. Write more, thats all I have to say. Literally, it
    seems as though you relied on the video to make your point.

    You obviously know what youre talking about, why throw
    away your intelligence on just posting videos to your weblog when you could be giving us something enlightening to read?

    My web page: blog analysis (mauriciowmgn.blog.com)

  32. brent.to says:

    Manage the Nature jailbreak software. It’s not upgradeable to 4G
    (unlike the Xoom, that may be given a free LTE update shortly).
    The iPad review on CNET is merely one among several.

  33. pinterest says:

    Make your images, videos, and infographics easy to pin by placing them on the page rather
    than displayed as a background. Google+ is a social networking site that has a range of different features that you can use to connect with patients and other healthcare professionals.
    For example, if your food business is dedicated to gourmet
    party appetizers your bio might be as simple as
    “Gourmet appetizers delivered right to your door.

    my web blog pinterest

  34. Can you tell us more about this? I’d love to find out
    more details.

    Here is my web site website creators

  35. But, ignoring this task can mean you might have people you do not
    understand taking a look at your account. This method will take a long
    time again. This person isn’t operating with a complete

  36. Don’t worry we are just joking this is truly the call
    for the number 43! The indication on the cusp of the 5th house tells that story.

    Would I want the VMFA to deaccession every thing it’s?
    Afterwards, the ball is in your court, my friend.

  37. anxiety says:

    Lets begin with stating among the information about this excellent revolutionary
    weight-reduction plan capsule and metabolism price
    booster. Safety is also assured when taking Adiphene because of its
    natural ingredients, which means that serious side effects
    are unlikely to happen if taken as directed.

    Adiphene Weight Loss Supplements Offers a Unique
    25% Discount n select package fr Online B Worldwide If the online
    critiques are something to go by, Adiphene is an efficient weight-loss option.

    Here is my web site anxiety

  38. Hmm it seems like your website ate my first comment (it was extremely long) so I
    guess I’ll just sum it up what I submitted and say, I’m thoroughly
    enjoying your blog. I as well am an aspiring blog writer but I’m still new to everything.
    Do you have any suggestions for novice blog writers? I’d
    genuinely appreciate it.


Leave a Comment

Powered by WordPress | Theme Credit